This is a Flickr badge showing public photos and videos from New Media Literacies. Make your own badge here.
The Gendered Participation Gap: Training Women in Developing Countries to Teach New Media Literacies
By Ioana Literat on October 20, 2010 2:16 AM
|Permalink
"As a woman, what is your role in society?", I
asked my 8th grade Indian students at the Railway Girls High School
in Hyderabad, India. As the coordinator of The Modern Story program, I was
implementing a digital storytelling curriculum at their school and this was to
be their homework assignment for next class.
When next class came around and it was time to
read their homework, nobody raised their hands.
Then Hajra, an otherwise timid 8th
grade math whiz, got up from her desk and proclaimed: "As a woman, the first
thing you have to do is to stand up."
"As a woman, I have more responsibilities to do in
society," said little Sarala, continuing the conversation. "I will help girls
get education and explain to them the importance of education for their future."
She does not look older than 10, but her smile carries a certain trace of
wisdom and experience.
"I can do official work two times better than the
man," says Navya proudly. "Though it is hard to do official and domestic work
too, women have the capacity to do it."
If only they had the chance. In India, like in
many other parts of the developing world, gender equality is an uphill battle,
and the earliest signs of this disempowerment manifest themselves in the
scarcity of educational and professional development opportunities that are
available to women.
One of the three principal challenges to the
acquisition of new media literacies (NMLs) is the participation gap, which Henry
Jenkins describes as "the unequal access to the opportunities, experiences,
skills and knowledge that will prepare youth for full participation in the
world of tomorrow." In the case of young women in India and in other developing
countries, the participation gap goes beyond restricted access; it is a
question of stunted self-efficacy and muffled voices.
In this research community, we talk about the
participation gap in terms of the students' acquisition of NML skills, yet, in
my personal experience in international education, I have found that it
similarly applies to teachers, and especially to female educators. The teachers
that are placed in public schools are victims of the same inequality of access
that characterizes their students. Compared to Western teachers, or even
educators in private schools, the teachers in government schools are denied the
professional development opportunities that allow them to take part in
meaningful communities - digital and non-digital alike - and to cultivate the
NML skills that they hope to pass down to their students.
For this reason, I cannot insist enough on the
crucial nature of equitable, culturally relevant teacher training programs, and
particularly NML professional development initiatives such as PLAY!. Training
local teachers in these skills not only helps alleviate the participation gap
that is hindering their personal and professional enrichment, but also builds
program sustainability, to ensure a scalable and responsible implementation of
NML initiatives abroad.
Before starting my doctoral program at USC
Annenberg, I worked in India as the field coordinator of The Modern Story
(TMS), a non-profit organization that teaches digital storytelling to children
of daily wage workers from traditionally underserved religious and caste
minorities, helping them acquire 21st century technological skills while
sharing stories of personal, social and environmental relevance. Having
identified the problem of the participation gap and its disempowering effects
on young girls and female teachers alike, we piloted an NML professional
development program that trained young female teachers in NML pedagogy and then
placed them in classrooms in all-girls public schools.
We managed to do this through a fantastic
collaboration with Technology for the People (TFTP), which made me realize the
potential of capitalizing on the target population's practical skills to build
NML capacity. A paragon of social innovation, TFTP is a Hyderabad-based NGO
that taps into the creative potential of young Muslim women (aged 18-22), who
are skilled in Henna tattoos and silk embroidery, by training them in
multimedia software and animation as a strategy of social and economic
empowerment. Identifying our strikingly similar core values and objectives, TMS
and TFTP collaborated to design a symbiotic program that simultaneously aided these
two underserved population segments (female public school students and,
respectively, young Muslim women), with a focus on education and livelihood
promotion as inextricably linked processes. After training the TFTP women in
NMLs through the use of multimedia "hard" and "soft"
technologies, as well as in the pedagogy of implementing such curricula in
schools, TMS employed these young women as teachers in government schools,
working alongside TMS fellows. The women thus gained valuable professional
experience, and a sustainable income, which offers economic freedom,
confidence, and social independence in their conservative Muslim communities.
Putting their NML skills in action, during their
professional development sessions, the young women created a video explaining
the training they are receiving in their own words. The video was written,
filmed and edited entirely by them, as a culmination of their training module:
The principal problems for these Muslim women
living in the Hyderabad slums relate to the oppressive, patriarchal environment
they live in. They are forced to drop out of school at young ages and take up
full-time domestic and craft work, usually within the confines of their homes.
However, they sustain their hunger for learning and self-betterment and have
overcome substantial obstacles to continue the TFTP and TMS training; many of
them commute for hours by bus to reach the center, many had to defy their
families and suffer verbal and physical abuse from their fathers, brothers, and
husbands.
Teaching these young women how to use technologies
of such current relevance and hone their NML skills is an enormous step towards
their individual empowerment, professional development and economic
independence. By offering them employment that brings a secure monthly income, they
can escape the "time poverty" trap by contributing to their families
in ways other than performing domestic chores and craftwork. Because of the
patriarchal norms that characterize these women's conservative Muslim
environment, their families often prohibit them from working in the commercial
media and animation industries, as it requires being in public atmospheres
around men. Our project aimed to work around this social prohibition by
providing them with jobs that are seen as highly respectable for women:
teaching in all-girls government schools. This new-found economic self-reliance
and mode of expression gives these women self-confidence; they are able to
transcend social boundaries that limit their development. Beyond their
vocational and professional development, the training greatly enhanced their
status in their communities, as they learned to act as role models to the
younger generation of girls in these conservative Muslim neighborhoods.